In
1964, Jean-Luc Godard made an entertaining little
film about two would-be gangsters who plot to steal
money from a girlfriend’s villa. Shot modestly
in black and white the year after his big-budget,
CinemaScope Contempt appeared, Godard’s
Band of Outsiders feels jarringly quaint
today—and therein lies its considerable charm,
I think.
The two ‘gangsters’ (Franz and Arthur)
boyishly tear around Paris in a beat-up sports car
and play-act Billy the Kid’s death-by-gunfire
as if they were kids in a friend’s backyard.
In an English class, they pass notes, make childish
faces and defy their teacher with harmless adolescent
gestures. Odile, the timid girlfriend underplayed
brilliantly by Anna Karina in a schoolgirl’s
plaid skirt and knee socks, goes along with the
robbery scheme largely because she has fallen in
love with Arthur (she starts the film as Franz’s
boyfriend). Even the robbery itself seems hopelessly,
even comically, naïve.
Band of Outsiders was adapted from an
American novel that was a part of the same Série
Noire publications that produced the source
material for François Truffaut’s own
gangster film, Shoot the Piano Player.
But as is often the case with Godard, Band of
Outsiders’s seemingly straightforward
noir / love triangle plot is in many ways simply
a springboard for his wide-ranging cultural explorations.
In fact, the references are so numerous that the
film sometimes feels like its storyline exists simply
to hold the allusions together. From Rimbaud to
The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, from T.S. Eliot
to Charlie Chaplin, Band of Outsiders’s
allusions could hog-tie a graduate seminar for a
week—and that’s assuming they skip over
the film’s fleeting (and now stunningly obscure)
references to a French furniture ad campaign (“Bravo,
Mr. Segot. That’s real furniture!”)
and a French drugstore chain. (The reference to
Hanna Barbera’s cartoon character Loopy de
Loop should prove easier.)
Some of the references are legitimately relevant
to the film’s thematic interests. (The multiple
references to former surrealist Raymond Queneau’s
novel Odile are particularly important.)
Others are simply the unavoidable, stream-of-consciousness
riffs of an improvisatory artist intensely preoccupied
with exploring common ground between high and low
cultures. Sami Frey’s character, for example,
is named Franz because Godard thought the actor
looked remarkably similar to Franz Kafka. (He does.)
Thematically, it doesn’t add anything to the
film, but it nicely underlines Godard’s fluid,
associative concept of filmmaking. At their most
extreme, Godard’s references can become hysterically—if
unintentionally—funny: he once called Truffaut
“the Ursula Andress of political militancy.”
Who else but Godard could come up with such a phrase?
In Band of Outsiders, though, he manages
to tuck his allusions—numerous as they are—into
the story so they don’t stick out so jarringly.
Band of Outsiders likewise draws from
Godard’s standard bag of cinematic tricks
without inordinately disturbing the film’s
narrative flow. As Godard aficionados would expect,
for instance, the soundtrack often stops abruptly
mid-phrase rather than fade out (as, say, Truffaut
might have it do; Godard doesn’t want us to
forget we’re watching a film, not ‘real
life’). He follows a similar tactic when the
trio delightfully dances the Madison: the music
periodically stops so the narrator (Godard himself)
can describe the characters’ thoughts. Ironically,
as spontaneous as the one-take scene feels, Anna
Karina reports in a 2002 interview recorded for
the new Criterion DVD release of Band of Outsiders
that it was the result of two or three weeks’
worth of rehearsals. But its fresh, playfully exuberant
quality contrasts favorably with the rather stilted—if
vaunted—dance scene in Pulp Fiction.
That’s not to say that the film is entirely
clear at first glance—or second. As Raoul
Coutard, the film’s cinemaphotographer, reports
in an informative interview included on the Criterion
DVD, French films of the period were expected to
be a certain length, and when he found Band
of Outsiders was running short, Godard simply
filmed his actors reading newspapers aloud and padded
the running time a bit. So much for finding profundities
behind Godard’s obscure devices.
Nonetheless, the frequently annoying indulgences
for which Godard is known are joyously missing in
Band of Outsiders. In fact, the film’s
tone is so gentle and charming that casual viewers
might be surprised at Godard’s subversive
intentions. In a short excerpt from a 1964 interview
included on the Criterion DVD, Godard declared that
This film was made as a reaction to anything
that wasn’t done. It was almost pathological
or systematic. “A wide-angle lens isn’t
used for close-ups? Then let’s do it.”
“A handheld camera isn’t used for
tracking shots? Then let’s do it.”
It went along with my desire to show that nothing
was off-limits. An Inquisition-like regime ruled
over French cinema. Everything was compartmentalized.
It was difficult for anyone younger than forty
or fifty to make any inroads. There were taboos
and laws, and I wanted to show that it all meant
nothing. The rules meant something when they were
first invented, but when people began to merely
copy them, it’s like I always say—When
Carné made Port of Shadows, he
made a great film because it reflected his era.
He was twenty-nine years old at the time. It’s
a great film. But with Les Tricheurs
he made a bad movie. He was imitating, following
the routine, without the inventiveness of before.
The point of the New Wave was to go against that.
Happily, Godard’s revolutionary efforts in
Band of Outsiders are quietly
subversive, and the film should be particularly
appealing to those cinephiles who find Godard’s
standard fare too alienating for their tastes. I
defy anyone to keep a straight face while watching
the trio try to break the record for the fastest
tour through the Louvre. Taken at a sprint and seeming
to take the guards and other visitors by surprise,
the actors laugh and slide with all the exuberance
the early New Wave movement could evoke. Heady,
impenetrable political films may have lain only
a few years off for Godard, but Band of Outsiders
is a delightful little time capsule.
|